Weyoun/chess
1
0
Fork 0
Code Issues 3 Pull Requests 1 Actions Packages Projects Releases Wiki Activity
chess/planning/analysis/implementation-metrics.md
Christoph Wagner 5ad0700b41 refactor: Consolidate repository structure - flatten from workspace pattern 
Restructured project from nested workspace pattern to flat single-repo layout.
This eliminates redundant nesting and consolidates all project files under version control.

## Migration Summary

**Before:**
```
alex/ (workspace, not versioned)
├── chess-game/ (git repo)
│   ├── js/, css/, tests/
│   └── index.html
└── docs/ (planning, not versioned)
```

**After:**
```
alex/ (git repo, everything versioned)
├── js/, css/, tests/
├── index.html
├── docs/ (project documentation)
├── planning/ (historical planning docs)
├── .gitea/ (CI/CD)
└── CLAUDE.md (configuration)
```

## Changes Made

### Structure Consolidation
- Moved all chess-game/ contents to root level
- Removed redundant chess-game/ subdirectory
- Flattened directory structure (eliminated one nesting level)

### Documentation Organization
- Moved chess-game/docs/ → docs/ (project documentation)
- Moved alex/docs/ → planning/ (historical planning documents)
- Added CLAUDE.md (workspace configuration)
- Added IMPLEMENTATION_PROMPT.md (original project prompt)

### Version Control Improvements
- All project files now under version control
- Planning documents preserved in planning/ folder
- Merged .gitignore files (workspace + project)
- Added .claude/ agent configurations

### File Updates
- Updated .gitignore to include both workspace and project excludes
- Moved README.md to root level
- All import paths remain functional (relative paths unchanged)

## Benefits

✅ **Simpler Structure** - One level of nesting removed
✅ **Complete Versioning** - All documentation now in git
✅ **Standard Layout** - Matches open-source project conventions
✅ **Easier Navigation** - Direct access to all project files
✅ **CI/CD Compatible** - All workflows still functional

## Technical Validation

- ✅ Node.js environment verified
- ✅ Dependencies installed successfully
- ✅ Dev server starts and responds
- ✅ All core files present and accessible
- ✅ Git repository functional

## Files Preserved

**Implementation Files:**
- js/ (3,517 lines of code)
- css/ (4 stylesheets)
- tests/ (87 test cases)
- index.html
- package.json

**CI/CD Pipeline:**
- .gitea/workflows/ci.yml
- .gitea/workflows/release.yml

**Documentation:**
- docs/ (12+ documentation files)
- planning/ (historical planning materials)
- README.md

**Configuration:**
- jest.config.js, babel.config.cjs, playwright.config.js
- .gitignore (merged)
- CLAUDE.md

🤖 Generated with [Claude Code](https://claude.com/claude-code)

Co-Authored-By: Claude <noreply@anthropic.com>
2025-11-23 10:05:26 +01:00

14 KiB
Raw Blame History

Implementation Metrics Report

HTML Chess Game - Hive Mind Swarm Analysis

Generated: 2025-11-22 Analyst Agent: Primary Metrics Monitor Session: Hive Mind Coordination Session Status: 🔴 CRITICAL - IMPLEMENTATION NOT STARTED

Executive Summary

CURRENT STATE: Project is in planning phase. No implementation code exists yet.

RISK LEVEL: 🟢 LOW (appropriate stage for planning) READINESS: Documentation complete, ready for implementation NEXT PHASE: Implementation can begin immediately

1. Implementation Progress Metrics

1.1 Overall Progress by Phase

Phase Features Status Progress Est. Hours Actual Hours
Phase 1: MVP 15 features 🔴 Not Started 0% 40-50 0
Phase 2: Enhanced 12 features ⚪ Pending 0% 25-35 0
Phase 3: AI 10 features ⚪ Pending 0% 30-40 0
Phase 4: Advanced 6 features ⚪ Pending 0% 20-30 0
TOTAL 43 features 0% 0% 115-155 0

1.2 Component Breakdown

Core Chess Engine (0% Complete)

  • Move Validation: Not started
  • Game State Management: Not started
  • Check Detection: Not started
  • Checkmate Detection: Not started
  • Special Moves (Castling, En Passant): Not started

Expected Complexity: HIGH (9/10) Estimated Effort: 30-40 hours Current Files: 0 Test Coverage: 0%

User Interface (0% Complete)

  • Board Rendering: Not started
  • Piece Display: Not started
  • Interaction Handlers: Not started
  • Visual Feedback: Not started

Expected Complexity: MEDIUM (6/10) Estimated Effort: 20-25 hours Current Files: 0 Test Coverage: 0%

AI Opponent (0% Complete)

  • Minimax Algorithm: Not started
  • Position Evaluation: Not started
  • Alpha-Beta Pruning: Not started
  • Web Workers: Not started

Expected Complexity: HIGH (8/10) Estimated Effort: 25-35 hours Current Files: 0 Test Coverage: 0%

2. Code Quality Metrics

2.1 Test Coverage

Target: ≥ 90% Current: 0% (no tests written) Status: 🔴 CRITICAL

Component Target Coverage Current Coverage Tests Written
Chess Engine 95% 0% 0
Move Validation 98% 0% 0
AI Engine 85% 0% 0
UI Components 80% 0% 0
State Management 90% 0% 0
Utilities 95% 0% 0

Action Required: Implement TDD approach - write tests first

2.2 Code Complexity

Target: Cyclomatic Complexity < 15 Current: N/A (no code) Status: ⚪ PENDING

Planned Complexity Estimates:

  • Chess Engine: 20-30 (High)
  • Move Validation: 30-40 (Very High)
  • AI Engine: 15-25 (High)
  • UI Components: 10-15 (Medium)
  • State Management: 10-15 (Medium)

2.3 Code Quality Score

Target: A grade Current: N/A Status: ⚪ PENDING

Quality Gates Defined:

  • ✅ ESLint configuration prepared
  • ✅ TypeScript/JSDoc standards documented
  • ✅ Code review process defined
  • 🔴 No code to analyze yet

3. Performance Metrics

3.1 Page Load Performance

Target: < 1s First Contentful Paint Current: N/A (not deployed) Status: ⚪ PENDING

Baseline Targets Set:

  • First Contentful Paint: < 500ms
  • Time to Interactive: < 2s
  • Bundle Size: < 100KB (gzipped < 40KB)

3.2 AI Response Time

Target: < 1s (beginner), < 2s (intermediate) Current: N/A (not implemented) Status: ⚪ PENDING

Performance Budgets Defined:

  • Beginner AI (depth 3-4): < 500ms
  • Intermediate AI (depth 5-6): < 1.5s
  • Advanced AI (depth 7+): < 5s

3.3 Animation Performance

Target: 60 FPS Current: N/A Status: ⚪ PENDING

Optimization Strategies Planned:

  • CSS Transforms (GPU acceleration)
  • RequestAnimationFrame
  • DOM diffing (update only changed squares)

4. Feature Implementation Status

4.1 MVP Features (Phase 1) - 0/15 Complete

CRITICAL Features (P0)

Feature ID Feature Name Status Priority Effort
F1 Chess Board Rendering 🔴 Not Started P0 8h
F2 Piece Placement 🔴 Not Started P0 6h
F3 Basic Move Execution 🔴 Not Started P0 4h
F4 Move Validation (Basic) 🔴 Not Started P0 12h
F5 Pawn Move Validation 🔴 Not Started P0 6h
F6 Turn Management 🔴 Not Started P0 3h
F7 Capture Mechanics 🔴 Not Started P0 4h
F8 Check Detection 🔴 Not Started P0 8h
F9 Checkmate Detection 🔴 Not Started P0 8h
F10 Stalemate Detection 🔴 Not Started P0 4h
F11 New Game Button 🔴 Not Started P0 2h
F15 Game Status Display 🔴 Not Started P0 3h

Progress: 0/12 (0%)

HIGH Priority Features (P1)

Feature ID Feature Name Status Priority Effort
F12 Undo Move 🔴 Not Started P1 5h
F13 Move Highlighting 🔴 Not Started P1 4h
F14 Legal Move Indicators 🔴 Not Started P1 5h

Progress: 0/3 (0%)

4.2 Phase 2 Features - 0/12 Complete

Status: ⚪ PENDING (waiting for MVP)

4.3 Phase 3 Features (AI) - 0/10 Complete

Status: ⚪ PENDING (waiting for Phase 2)

5. Risk Assessment & Status

5.1 Current Risk Status

Risk Severity Probability Status Mitigation
Chess Rules Compliance CRITICAL 80% 🟢 MANAGED TDD approach planned, test suite designed
Performance Degradation HIGH 70% 🟢 PLANNED Web Workers, alpha-beta pruning documented
Browser Compatibility MEDIUM-HIGH 60% 🟢 PLANNED Progressive enhancement strategy ready
Scope Creep HIGH 85% 🟢 CONTROLLED MVP strictly defined (15 features only)
Insufficient Testing HIGH 75% 🟡 NEEDS ATTENTION TDD required from start
Knowledge Gap HIGH 70% 🟢 MITIGATED Chess rules documented, test cases prepared
Timeline Underestimation MEDIUM 80% 🟢 BUFFERED 30-50% buffer included in estimates

5.2 Blockers & Dependencies

CURRENT BLOCKERS: None (ready to start implementation)

DEPENDENCIES READY:

  • ✅ Requirements documented
  • ✅ Architecture designed
  • ✅ Test cases defined
  • ✅ Performance budgets set
  • ✅ Risk mitigations planned

NEXT STEPS:

  1. Begin Phase 1 implementation
  2. Set up test framework
  3. Implement board rendering (F1)
  4. Create CI/CD pipeline

6. Success Criteria Tracking

6.1 Critical Success Metrics (Must Pass All)

Metric Target Current Status Notes
Test Coverage ≥ 90% 0% ⚪ PENDING Will track from first sprint
Critical Bugs 0 0 🟢 PASS No code = no bugs (yet)
Chess Rules Compliance 100% 0% ⚪ PENDING Test suite ready
AI Response Time < 1s N/A ⚪ PENDING Budgets defined
Lighthouse Score > 90 N/A ⚪ PENDING Optimization planned
Deadline Adherence 100% TBD 🟢 ON TRACK Week 0 of 6-week MVP

6.2 Feature Completion by Priority

Priority Target Features Completed Percentage Status
P0 (CRITICAL) 13 0 0% 🔴 Not Started
P1 (HIGH) 12 0 0% ⚪ Pending
P2 (MEDIUM) 16 0 0% ⚪ Pending
P3 (LOW) 6 0 0% ⚪ Deferred

6.3 Timeline Status

MVP Target: 4-6 weeks (40-50 hours) Current Sprint: Pre-implementation (Week 0) Elapsed Time: 0 days Status: 🟢 ON SCHEDULE

Milestones:

  • Week 2: Board rendering + basic moves (F1-F3)
  • Week 4: Full move validation + check/checkmate (F4-F10)
  • Week 6: MVP complete with UI polish (F11-F15)

7. Quality Gates

7.1 Sprint 0 Readiness (CURRENT PHASE)

Pre-Implementation Checklist:

  • ✅ Requirements documented
  • ✅ Architecture designed
  • ✅ Complexity analyzed
  • ✅ Risks identified and mitigated
  • ✅ Performance targets set
  • ✅ Feature prioritization complete
  • ✅ Success metrics defined
  • ✅ Code templates prepared
  • 🔴 Development environment setup (NEXT STEP)
  • 🔴 CI/CD pipeline setup (NEXT STEP)

Readiness Score: 8/10 ✅

7.2 Definition of Ready (for implementation start)

  • ✅ User stories written with acceptance criteria
  • ✅ Technical approach documented
  • ✅ Test cases defined
  • ✅ Dependencies identified
  • ✅ Estimation completed
  • 🔴 Development tools installed
  • 🔴 Repository initialized with starter files

Status: 83% Ready (5/6 items complete)

7.3 Definition of Done (for each feature)

Standards Defined:

  1. Code written and reviewed
  2. Unit tests written (≥ 90% coverage)
  3. Integration tests pass
  4. Manual testing completed
  5. Documentation updated
  6. No critical bugs
  7. Performance benchmarks met
  8. Accessibility standards met

8. Velocity Tracking

8.1 Sprint Velocity (Not Yet Established)

Baseline Sprint: TBD (will establish in Sprint 1)

Projected Velocity:

  • Conservative: 15-20 story points/sprint
  • Expected: 20-25 story points/sprint
  • Optimistic: 25-30 story points/sprint

8.2 Burndown Chart

Not applicable yet - will track from Sprint 1

9. Continuous Monitoring Plan

9.1 Daily Tracking (When Implementation Starts)

  • Build status (pass/fail)
  • Test coverage trend
  • Critical bug count
  • Commit frequency

9.2 Weekly Reviews

  • Sprint velocity
  • Feature completion rate
  • Technical debt accumulation
  • Risk status updates
  • Blocker resolution

9.3 Monthly Assessments

  • Milestone progress
  • User acceptance testing
  • Performance benchmarking
  • Accessibility audit
  • Security review

10. Recommendations for Queen Coordinator

10.1 IMMEDIATE ACTIONS REQUIRED

  1. ✅ GREEN LIGHT FOR IMPLEMENTATION

    • All planning artifacts complete
    • Architecture documented
    • Risks identified and mitigated
    • Team ready to begin coding

  2. 🎯 PRIORITY 1: Setup Development Environment

    • Initialize Git repository
    • Set up package.json with dependencies
    • Configure Jest for testing
    • Set up ESLint and Prettier
    • Create project folder structure

  3. 🎯 PRIORITY 2: Begin MVP Phase 1

    • Start with F1 (Board Rendering) - 8 hours
    • Implement TDD from first feature
    • Establish sprint cadence
    • Set up CI/CD pipeline

  4. ⚠️ WATCH FOR RED FLAGS

    • Test coverage falling below 85% (stop and write tests)
    • Any critical bugs discovered
    • Sprint velocity < 15 points (reassess estimates)
    • Scope creep attempts (enforce MVP freeze)

10.2 Resource Allocation Recommendations

Optimal Team Composition:

  • 1x Chess Engine Developer (40% time) - Core logic
  • 1x Frontend Developer (30% time) - UI/UX
  • 1x QA/Test Engineer (20% time) - Testing & validation
  • 1x Project Coordinator (10% time) - Tracking & reporting

Current Swarm Agents Available:

  • ✅ Coder agent (implementation)
  • ✅ Tester agent (test automation)
  • ✅ Reviewer agent (code quality)
  • ✅ Analyst agent (metrics tracking - ME!)

10.3 Success Probability Assessment

Overall Success Probability: 🟢 85% (HIGH CONFIDENCE)

Confidence Factors:

  • ✅ Excellent planning and documentation (9/10)
  • ✅ Risks identified and mitigated (8/10)
  • ✅ Clear scope and MVP definition (9/10)
  • ✅ Realistic timeline with buffers (8/10)
  • ⚠️ No code written yet (unknown unknowns)

Risk Factors:

  • ⚠️ Chess rules complexity (mitigated with TDD)
  • ⚠️ AI performance optimization (mitigated with plan)
  • ⚠️ Timeline pressure (mitigated with buffer)

11. Next Sprint Planning (Sprint 1)

11.1 Proposed Sprint 1 Goals (Week 1-2)

Sprint Goal: "Get chess board rendering with piece placement"

Features to Implement:

  • F1: Chess Board Rendering (8 hours)
  • F2: Piece Placement & Display (6 hours)
  • F3: Basic Move Execution (4 hours)
  • Setup: Dev environment, testing framework (4 hours)

Total Estimated Effort: 22 hours Sprint Capacity: 20-25 hours Status: ✅ ACHIEVABLE

11.2 Sprint 1 Success Criteria

  • 8x8 chess board visible in browser
  • All 32 pieces displayed correctly
  • Can click and move pieces (no validation yet)
  • Test coverage ≥ 80% for implemented features
  • CI/CD pipeline operational
  • No critical bugs

12. Memory Keys for Swarm Coordination

STORED IN COLLECTIVE MEMORY:

  • swarm/analyst/metrics - This report
  • swarm/analyst/sprint-1-plan - Next sprint details
  • swarm/analyst/risk-status - Risk tracking
  • swarm/analyst/baseline-metrics - Initial measurements

SHARED WITH QUEEN:

  • Implementation status: 0% complete, ready to begin
  • Risk level: 🟢 LOW (planning complete)
  • Recommendation: ✅ PROCEED WITH SPRINT 1
  • Next review: End of Sprint 1 (Week 2)

13. Conclusion

Current Status Summary

  • Planning Phase: ✅ COMPLETE (100%)
  • Implementation Phase: 🔴 NOT STARTED (0%)
  • Overall Readiness: 🟢 READY TO BEGIN

Key Findings

  1. ✅ Excellent preparation - All planning artifacts complete
  2. ✅ Clear path forward - MVP scope well-defined
  3. ✅ Risks managed - Mitigation strategies in place
  4. ✅ Realistic timeline - 6-week MVP achievable
  5. ⚠️ TDD critical - Must start with tests from day 1

Analyst's Recommendation to Queen

STATUS: 🟢 GREEN LIGHT FOR IMPLEMENTATION

The chess game project has completed exceptional planning and analysis. All documentation is thorough, risks are identified and mitigated, and the team is ready to begin implementation.

NEXT STEP: Proceed immediately with Sprint 1 - Board Rendering phase.

CONFIDENCE: HIGH (85% success probability)

Report Generated By: Analyst Agent (Hive Mind Swarm) Next Update: End of Sprint 1 (or immediately if critical blockers arise) Status: 📊 MONITORING READY TO BEGIN

Appendix A: Metric Definitions

See /Volumes/Mac maxi/Users/christoph/sources/alex/docs/analysis/success-metrics.md for detailed metric definitions and measurement methods.

Appendix B: Risk Details

See /Volumes/Mac maxi/Users/christoph/sources/alex/docs/analysis/risk-assessment.md for comprehensive risk analysis.

Appendix C: Feature Prioritization

See /Volumes/Mac maxi/Users/christoph/sources/alex/docs/analysis/feature-prioritization.md for complete feature breakdown.